Sell to Us
Your Quality Items Deserve a Second Stage.
Turn the things you no longer need into cash — and into something someone else will love. At The Tithing Thrifters, your gently-used pieces find a purposeful new home in a boutique setting built for beautiful, intentional things.
No guesswork. No hassle. Just bring your best — we'll take care of the rest.
How Selling Works
We've made the process simple, transparent, and respectful of your time. Here's what to expect from start to finish.
01
Bring Your Items In
No appointment needed for standard drop-offs. Gather your clean, quality items and bring them to our store during business hours. Our team will greet you and get you checked in quickly.
02
We Evaluate & Price
Our buyers assess each item for condition, brand, style, and how well it fits our curated boutique aesthetic. We price competitively based on resale market value. This typically takes 24–48 hours for standard submissions.
03
You Get Paid
If your items are selected, you'll receive payment promptly — either in-store cash or store credit (store credit earns a bonus percentage). Items not selected are returned to you or, with your permission, donated to our community partners.
04
Your Items Find a New Home
Selected pieces are priced, tagged, and lovingly placed in our boutique — where they'll be discovered by someone who'll treasure them. And with every sale, 10% of our proceeds support Christian charities doing real good in the world.
What We Buy
We look for quality items that fit our boutique aesthetic — things that are clean, gently used, on-trend or classically timeless, and ready to be loved again. Below are the categories we actively purchase and the condition standards we hold ourselves (and our inventory) to.
Apparel & Accessories
Women's, men's, and children's clothing, shoes, handbags, belts, jewelry, and scarves. We love quality brands, vintage silhouettes, and well-preserved contemporary pieces.
Furniture
Solid wood tables, chairs, sofas, bookshelves, dressers, side tables, and accent pieces. Must be structurally sound, clean, and free of major damage. Pickup may be available for large pieces — ask us.
Home Décor
Vases, mirrors, frames, candles, trays, baskets, artwork, wall décor, and intentional accent pieces that complement a warm, curated living space.
Books
Hardcovers, quality paperbacks, coffee table books, Christian living titles, cookbooks, design books, and children's classics. Must be clean and free of heavy marking or damage.
Kitchenware & Linens
Dishes, glassware, serving pieces, cast iron, quality cookware, tablecloths, and textile goods in excellent condition.
Vintage & Antique Finds
One-of-a-kind pieces with history — aged signage, vintage ceramics, antique frames, retro kitchenware, and collectibles that tell a story.
Plants & Planters
Healthy houseplants, ceramic planters, decorative pots, and botanical accessories that add life to any space.
Holiday & Seasonal
Quality holiday décor, seasonal textiles, and curated gift items. Accepted on a seasonal rotation — ask our team for current needs.
Other Unique Finds
If it's quality, curated, and one-of-a-kind, we want to see it. When in doubt, bring it in — our buyers love a good discovery.
Condition Standards We Look For
- Clean, laundered, or surface-wiped — ready to sell as-is
- Free of stains, tears, odors, pet hair, and heavy wear
- Structurally intact (furniture: no wobbly joints, missing hardware, or broken frames)
- Matching sets complete (e.g., dish sets, bed linens)
- Current or classically timeless in style
Items that do not meet our standards will be returned to the seller or, with permission, donated — never discarded without your consent.
Seller FAQs
A few of the questions we hear most from sellers. Don't see yours? Reach out — we're always happy to talk.
Do I need an appointment to sell items?
No appointment is necessary for standard clothing, accessories, books, and small décor items. For furniture or larger loads, we recommend calling ahead so we can ensure we have the staff and space to receive you efficiently. Walk-ins are always welcome during business hours.How do you decide what to buy and what to pass on?
Our buyers evaluate each item based on condition, style fit with our boutique aesthetic, current inventory levels, and estimated resale value. We aim to be selective so our shelves stay curated and our customers always find something worth discovering. It's not a reflection of an item's inherent worth — just its fit for our current inventory.How quickly will I get a decision and payment?
For smaller loads brought in during business hours, we typically complete our review within 24–48 hours. If you're present during drop-off and the load is manageable, we may be able to provide a same-day offer. Payment is issued as in-store cash or store credit — store credit earns a bonus percentage on top of the offer value.What happens to items you don't select?
Items we pass on are returned to you. If you prefer not to take them back, we can accept them as a donation with your written permission — those items support our charitable giving model. We will never discard or redistribute your items without your explicit consent.Do you offer consignment?
Currently, our primary model is outright purchase — we buy items directly and pay you at the time of acceptance. We do not offer a traditional consignment program at this time, though this may evolve as we grow. Check back or contact us for updates.Can I donate items instead of selling them?
Absolutely — and we'd love that. Donated items allow us to give more generously through our 10% charitable giving model. Visit our Donate page to learn what we accept and how donations work.Visit Donate Page
Thank you! We've received your message and will be in touch within one business day.
Ready to Sell?
Bring Your Best. We'll Handle the Rest.
Have questions about our sell-to-us program, want to schedule a large drop-off, or just want to know if your items are a good fit? Fill out the form below and our team will get back to you within one business day. We love meeting our sellers — every great item starts with someone like you.
Prefer to call or email directly? Use the contact details on our Contact page .
